Backward vs total task chaining
Backward chaining has the learner perform only the final untaught steps while the adult completes the rest, whereas total task chaining has the learner attempt every step on every trial, with prompts wherever needed. The question is whether the adult does part of the task for the learner.
What is the difference between backward and total task chaining?
Backward chaining isolates the last step for teaching. The adult does or fully prompts all earlier steps, and the learner completes the end, then gradually takes over earlier steps. Total task chaining teaches all steps at once: the learner works through the whole sequence each time, receiving prompts on unmastered steps and doing mastered ones alone.
Total task chaining gives more practice per trial, since the learner touches every step. That suits learners who can already do several steps or who need the whole routine to make sense, such as following a morning schedule.
Backward chaining narrows the teaching target and makes sure every trial ends in success, which can help a learner who finds long tasks frustrating.
Backward and total task chaining side by side
| Backward chaining | Total task chaining | |
|---|---|---|
| Steps the learner attempts | Only the last step or steps being taught | Every step, every trial |
| Adult's role on other steps | Completes or fully prompts them | Prompts as needed, then fades |
| Practice per trial | Lower | Higher |
| Good fit | Long or frustrating tasks; strong pull toward the end result | Learners with some steps already mastered |
| Reinforcement | Terminal reinforcer every trial | Terminal reinforcer every trial, plus praise for independent steps |
| Data | Step being taught, plus probes | Every step, every trial |
How do you tell backward and total task chaining apart on the exam?
Ask whether the learner touches every step. If the learner goes through the whole sequence each trial, getting help only where needed, it is total task chaining. If the adult does the earlier steps and the learner is responsible only for the last one or few, it is backward chaining. The word every is the giveaway for total task.
- Learner attempts all steps, prompted where needed: total task.
- Adult completes early steps, learner finishes: backward.
- Learner starts, adult finishes: forward.
Worked scenarios
Scenario 1. A learner brushing teeth is guided through all eight steps each session, with a gesture on steps she misses and nothing on steps she does alone. Answer: total task chaining.
Scenario 2. A technician puts the learner's shirt on over his head and arms, and the learner pulls it down to his waist. Answer: backward chaining, since only the final step is taught.
Scenario 3. A teenager learning laundry already loads the machine and adds soap. The plan has him attempt the whole routine every time, with a verbal prompt to choose the cycle. Answer: total task chaining.
Scenario 4. For a learner who gives up halfway through puzzles, the technician places all but the last piece, and the learner places it. Answer: backward chaining.
What are the common traps with backward and total task chaining?
One trap is assuming any chain with a full prompt on some steps must be backward chaining. In total task chaining, the learner can still need full prompts on unmastered steps; the difference is that the learner is attempting them. Another trap is forgetting that total task chaining collects data on every step, not just one target.
- Treating heavy prompting as proof of backward chaining.
- Recording only the target step in a total task program.
- Changing the method because a session felt slow, rather than asking the supervisor.
When would you see each in a session?
Total task chaining is common for routines a learner does many times a day, like washing hands or packing a bag, and for learners who already know several steps. Backward chaining shows up for tasks with a strong reward at the end or when frustration is high. Your supervisor sets the method, the prompts and the mastery rule for each step.
Whichever method is used, follow the prompt level written for each step and fade it only as the plan describes. Skipping ahead can create errors that are hard to undo.
Practice questions
Dev, 14, can already do most of the 12 steps of making a sandwich but needs help with spreading and cutting. Which chaining method is usually best suited for him?
Each time Arjun, 10, practices setting the table, he attempts all six steps from start to finish, and his technician prompts only the steps he misses. Which procedure is this?
To teach handwashing, the technician completes every step for the learner except the last one, drying hands, which the learner does independently. Once that is mastered, the learner also does the second-to-last step. Which procedure is this?
Mila, 6, keeps getting stuck on the toothbrushing step 'put toothpaste on brush,' even with prompts. Her supervisor rewrites it as three steps: open the cap, squeeze a small amount onto the bristles, close the cap. What has the supervisor done?
Questions people ask
Is total task chaining the same as forward chaining?
No. Forward chaining teaches the first step first. Total task chaining has the learner attempt every step on every trial.
Can a program switch from backward to total task chaining?
Yes, if the supervisor decides the learner is ready. The technician follows the updated plan.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness