Positive and negative reinforcement

Reinforcement is any consequence that makes a behavior more likely to happen again. In positive reinforcement something is added after the behavior; in negative reinforcement something is removed or avoided. "Positive" and "negative" describe adding or taking away, not good or bad.

What does task C.1 ask the technician to do?

Task C.1 asks you to use contingencies of reinforcement, such as positive and negative reinforcement and the schedules your plan specifies. You deliver the planned reinforcer immediately after the target behavior, only when the criterion is met, at the schedule written in the plan, and you record it. You also watch for signs that a reinforcer is losing value.

How do positive and negative reinforcement differ?

Both increase behavior. Positive reinforcement adds a stimulus after the behavior, such as a token, praise or a turn on the swing. Negative reinforcement removes or prevents a stimulus, such as ending a loud noise or taking away a hard task. Ask two questions: was something added or removed, and did the behavior increase afterwards?

Positive reinforcementNegative reinforcement
What happensSomething is addedSomething is removed or avoided
Effect on behaviorIncreasesIncreases
Clinic exampleLearner tidies blocks and gets a stickerLearner asks for a break and the work is moved away
Workplace exampleAdult sorts silverware and earns pointsAdult puts on ear defenders and the polisher noise stops bothering him

What makes reinforcement effective in practice?

Reinforcement works best when it is immediate, contingent on the target behavior, valuable to the learner right now, and sized appropriately. A delay of even a few seconds can reinforce whatever the learner did in between. Rotating reinforcers helps prevent satiation, and pairing tangible items with praise builds the value of social reinforcement over time.

Worked scenario: a learner correctly labels a bus. The technician writes the data, sets up the next card and then gives the token. By the time it arrives the learner is looking out of the window, so the token may strengthen looking away. Deliver first, then record.

Contingency matters too. If a learner gets tablet time every 10 minutes regardless of behavior, that access is not reinforcing any particular behavior. It may be part of a deliberate plan, but it is not contingent reinforcement.

Which reinforcement schedules will you implement?

Continuous reinforcement delivers a reinforcer after every correct response and is used for new skills. Intermittent schedules deliver only some of the time. Fixed ratio follows a set number of responses; variable ratio follows an average number. Fixed interval reinforces the first response after a set time; variable interval after an average time. The plan specifies which schedule applies.

ScheduleRuleExample
Continuous (CRF)Every correct responsePraise and a token for each correct coin name on a new target
Fixed ratio (FR)After a set number of responsesA point after every 5 items sorted
Variable ratio (VR)After an average number of responsesA high five after the 3rd, then 5th, then 4th correct answer
Fixed interval (FI)First response after a set timePraise for working, first time noticed after each 5 minutes
Variable interval (VI)First response after an average timeCheck-in praise at unpredictable times averaging 4 minutes

Which mix-ups cost exam points?

The biggest trap is calling negative reinforcement punishment. If the behavior increases, it is reinforcement, even if something unpleasant was involved. Other traps include labelling an item a reinforcer just because the learner likes it, confusing ratio with interval schedules, and treating noncontingent access as reinforcement of a target behavior. Always check what happened to future behavior.

  • Reinforcement increases behavior; punishment decreases it.
  • Positive adds; negative removes. Neither word means pleasant or unpleasant.
  • Ratio counts responses; interval counts time.

What is the RBT's role compared with the BCBA's?

The supervisor selects reinforcers and schedules, sets criteria and decides when to thin reinforcement. The technician delivers reinforcement as written, keeps it immediate and contingent, rotates items as the plan allows, records accurately and reports when a reinforcer seems to have lost its effect. Changing a schedule or swapping in a new reinforcer system is a decision for the supervisor.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior acquisition

Each time Maya, 6, puts her blocks back in the bin, her technician hands her a sticker. Over the next two weeks, Maya puts her blocks away more often. Which process does this show?

Question 2 · Behavior acquisition

Jordan, 15, works at a vocational site where a loud floor polisher runs every afternoon. When he puts on his noise-reducing headphones, the noise becomes much quieter. Over several weeks he puts the headphones on sooner each afternoon. Which process explains the increase?

Question 3 · Behavior acquisition

Owen, 5, correctly labels a picture of a bus. His technician writes the data, sets up the next card, and about 90 seconds later says, 'Great job saying bus!' What is the main problem with this sequence?

Question 4 · Behavior acquisition

During math practice, a technician gives Andre, 11, a high five after his 3rd correct answer, then after 7 more, then after 4 more, then after 6 more. The number changes each time but averages 5. Which schedule is she using?

Question 5 · Behavior acquisition

Leo, 7, gets 2 minutes of tablet time every 10 minutes during his session, whether or not he has worked on his puzzles. His puzzle completion is not improving. Which feature of effective reinforcement is missing?

Questions people ask

Can problem behavior be negatively reinforced?

Yes. If a learner screams and a task is removed, screaming may increase. That is why escape-maintained behavior is common.

Is praise always a reinforcer?

No. For some learners praise has little value until it is paired with established reinforcers.

Why move from continuous to intermittent reinforcement?

Intermittent schedules make behavior more resistant to extinction and more like natural conditions. Your supervisor decides when to thin.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness