Side effects of extinction and punishment
Extinction and punishment both have predictable side effects. Extinction often brings a temporary burst, new forms of behavior, emotional responding and later spontaneous recovery, while punishment can produce avoidance, aggression and fear of the person or setting. Knowing them helps you stay consistent, keep everyone safe and report early.
Why does this outline task matter?
Task D.6 on the RBT Test Content Outline (3rd ed.) asks technicians to recognize the side effects of extinction and punishment. Side effects are the moments when plans most often fail, usually because an adult gives in during a burst or mistakes a predictable pattern for a sign the plan is not working. Recognizing them lets you respond as the plan intends.
What side effects does extinction produce?
When reinforcement stops, behavior often increases briefly in frequency, intensity or duration, called an extinction burst. The learner may try new behaviors, show frustration or aggression, or, after the behavior has faded, show it again briefly, called spontaneous recovery. If a replacement behavior also stops being reinforced, the old problem behavior can return, called resurgence.
| Side effect | What it looks like | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Extinction burst | Temporary increase when reinforcement first stops | Door slamming jumps from 4 to 15 times on day one |
| Response variation | New forms of behavior appear | A learner who pushed materials away now also drops to the floor |
| Emotional responding | Crying, frustration or aggression | A learner who was never aggressive pushes the technician during the first days |
| Spontaneous recovery | Behavior reappears after it had stopped | Table banging returns briefly after a long weekend |
| Resurgence | Old behavior returns when a newer behavior stops paying off | Screaming returns when staff stop answering the excuse-me card |
What side effects does punishment produce?
Punishment can lead a learner to avoid the person, materials or room linked with it, to become aggressive or emotional, or to suppress behavior only while the punishing adult is present. It may also model punishing behavior and, because it often stops behavior quickly, tempt adults to overuse it. These risks are part of why reinforcement-based approaches come first.
School example: after response cost is added in the speech room, a learner starts hiding before sessions. That avoidance is a side effect the supervisor needs to hear about, even though the target behavior in the room may have dropped.
How should you respond to an extinction burst?
If the behavior is getting worse but stays safe, keep following the plan exactly. A burst usually means extinction is in contact with the behavior. Giving in at the peak teaches the learner that louder or longer behavior pays off, which can create a more intense problem. If safety is at risk, follow the plan's safety steps and contact the supervisor.
Worked scenario: during the first week of extinction, yelling hits its loudest point and a relative hands over the phone to stop it. The next day yelling starts louder and lasts longer. The data should show that, with a note on what happened, so the supervisor can respond.
- Expect the burst and prepare caregivers for it before extinction starts, as the supervisor directs
- Keep your response calm and the same across every adult
- Reinforce the replacement behavior the moment it appears
- Record frequency and intensity so the supervisor can see the burst and its end
- Report new behaviors, aggression or anything unsafe the same day
Which exam traps involve these side effects?
Candidates often confuse an extinction burst with spontaneous recovery. A burst comes early, right after reinforcement stops; spontaneous recovery comes later, after behavior had already decreased. Resurgence is different again: it follows extinction of a newer replacement behavior. Another trap treats a burst as proof the plan failed, when it is usually an expected sign of extinction.
What is the technician's role when side effects appear?
Stay consistent, keep everyone safe, record accurately and report quickly. Deciding to stop extinction, change a punishment procedure or add a new strategy belongs to the BCBA. Your detailed notes about when a side effect started, what it looked like and how intense it was are what make that decision possible, so objective description matters more than interpretation.
Compare two notes. One says the learner was very angry about the new plan. The other says the learner pushed the technician twice in the first ten minutes, a behavior not seen before, after attention was withheld for whining. Only the second gives the supervisor something to act on.
Practice questions
After a team stops giving attention for whining, the whining briefly becomes louder and more frequent. What is the most likely explanation?
After three weeks of extinction, Tess's table banging dropped to zero. On the Monday after a long weekend, she bangs the table a few times, even though the behavior still produces no reinforcement. What is this called?
Felix's screaming for attention was replaced by handing staff an "excuse me" card. On a short-staffed day, no one responds to the card for a long stretch, and Felix begins screaming again. What is this most likely?
Before escape extinction began, Marta, 6, only pushed her materials away. Now that pushing no longer ends tasks, she also covers her ears, slides under the table and says "no" loudly. What is this?
After response cost is added to Lina's sessions in the speech room, she starts hiding under the coat rack when it is time to go to that room. What does this most likely show?
Questions people ask
Does every extinction procedure produce a burst?
Not always, but it is common enough that plans and caregivers should be prepared for one.
Does spontaneous recovery mean extinction failed?
No. It is a typical pattern; continuing the plan consistently usually lets the behavior fade again.
Can side effects be reduced?
Pairing extinction with strong reinforcement for a replacement behavior, as plans usually do, tends to soften them.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness