Prompt dependence
Prompt dependence is when a learner responds only after a prompt and rarely responds to the natural cue alone. The prompt has taken over control of the behavior. It usually develops when prompts are not faded or when they come too fast.
What is prompt dependence?
Prompt dependence means the learner can respond correctly with a prompt but waits for it, or looks for the adult's cue, before responding. The behavior is under the control of the prompt instead of the instruction or situation. It is a teaching problem to prevent, not a flaw in the learner.
It tends to grow when prompts are delivered at the same level too long, when they arrive before the learner has time to try, or when the adult's cues are subtle but constant, such as a glance at the answer.
What does prompt dependence look like in a session?
You give the instruction and the learner freezes, looks at you, or reaches only after you move. Data show prompted-correct responses for many sessions but few independent ones. The learner may be accurate with help but unable to do the skill when you step back.
Worked example: a learner can set the table when you point at each place. When you stop pointing, he stands still and looks at your hand. Data show 18 prompted trials and two independent ones over a month. That pattern, not a single bad day, suggests dependence. Report it so the supervisor can adjust the fading plan.
How is prompt dependence different from a skill deficit?
With a skill deficit the learner cannot perform the response even with help, or errs repeatedly. With prompt dependence the learner performs correctly when prompted but not without it. The first calls for more teaching of the response; the second calls for better prompt fading and more opportunities to respond independently.
| Pattern | Likely cause | Team response |
|---|---|---|
| Correct only with prompts, for many sessions | Prompt dependence | Review and speed up fading |
| Errors even with prompts | Skill not yet acquired | Adjust teaching steps or prompt type |
| Correct alone, then declines weeks later | Maintenance problem | Review maintenance plan |
What exam traps involve prompt dependence?
Exam scenarios describe a learner who waits for a gesture and ask what to do. The answer is usually to follow a plan for fading prompts or to tell the supervisor, not to give more prompts or remove all help abruptly. Another trap is blaming the learner rather than the procedure.
- Prevention comes from fading, delaying prompts and reinforcing independent responses more.
- Continuing to prompt at the same level makes the problem worse.
- Removing every prompt suddenly may cause errors; change prompts as the plan states.
- Technicians report patterns; supervisors decide how to change the program.
How does an RBT prevent prompt dependence?
You follow the fading steps exactly, give the learner time to respond before prompting, reinforce independent responses more richly than prompted ones, and record prompt levels honestly. If data show a long run of prompted responses without progress, report it so your supervisor can revise the plan.
Pay attention to unintended cues in your own behavior, such as leaning toward the right card or pausing in a recognizable spot. Learners are quick to learn these. Keeping your cues consistent with the plan, and nothing more, protects independence.
Practice questions
Hannah, 8, now waits for her technician's gesture before answering on nearly every trial, even for targets she has answered correctly many times. Which approach best addresses this?
A learner reliably touches the correct card when the technician points to it. The plan says to move from the gesture prompt toward no prompt. What is this process called?
On new targets for Lucas, 5, the technician gives the SD and prompts the answer immediately. Over later sessions she waits 2 seconds before prompting, then 4 seconds, giving Lucas time to answer on his own. Which procedure is this?
After prompts began to be faded, Hana's number of independent toothbrushing steps across five sessions was 8, 7, 7, 5 and 4. Which description is accurate?
Questions people ask
Can prompt dependence happen with any kind of prompt?
Yes. Physical, gestural, verbal, model and visual prompts can all become something the learner waits for if they are not faded.
Should I stop prompting if I suspect prompt dependence?
Do not change the procedure on your own. Describe what you see and let your supervisor update the fading plan.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness