DRA vs DRO: how to tell them apart

DRA reinforces a specific replacement behavior, while DRO reinforces a stretch of time in which the problem behavior does not happen. Ask one question: does the learner have to do something particular to earn the reward? If yes, it is DRA. If the reward comes simply for going without the problem behavior, it is DRO.

What is DRA?

DRA, differential reinforcement of alternative behavior, delivers reinforcement when the learner uses a named replacement behavior and withholds it, as far as the plan allows, after the problem behavior. The replacement usually serves the same function, so the learner gets the same outcome a better way, such as handing over a break card instead of pushing materials away.

The key word is alternative. The plan spells out the behavior that earns the reward. Often it is a communication response, like saying "help" or tapping a card. Because the new behavior gets the learner what the old one did, it has a real reason to replace it.

What is DRO?

DRO, differential reinforcement of other behavior, delivers reinforcement when a set interval passes without the problem behavior. If the behavior occurs, the timer usually resets and the interval starts again. Nothing specific has to happen to earn the reward. The learner only has to get through the whole interval without the target behavior.

The name is a little misleading. No particular other behavior is taught or tracked. The supervisor usually sets a starting interval short enough for the learner to succeed, then lengthens it as the behavior drops. Your job is to run the timer exactly as written and reset it when the plan says to.

What is the one-question test for DRA vs DRO?

Ask what the learner must do to earn the reinforcer. If the scenario names a behavior the learner performs, such as asking, signing or completing a step, it is DRA. If the reinforcer arrives because time passed with no problem behavior, and nothing else is required, it is DRO. A timer that resets is the strongest clue.

  • Find the moment reinforcement is delivered.
  • Look at what happened right before it.
  • A named action by the learner points to DRA.
  • An interval with no problem behavior points to DRO.
  • If the action is physically impossible to do alongside the problem behavior, it is DRI, a kind of DRA.

DRA and DRO side by side

DRADRO
What earns reinforcementA named replacement behaviorAn interval with no problem behavior
Timer involvedUsually notYes; the problem behavior often resets it
Teaches a new skillYes, directlyNo skill is taught directly
Typical exampleTapping a break card instead of elopingA token for each 4 minutes without biting
Main riskReplacement is too hard or not reinforced fast enoughAnother unwanted behavior can be reinforced by accident

How do you classify DRA and DRO in a scenario?

Read each scenario for the trigger of reinforcement, not for the problem behavior it mentions. Problem behavior appears in both procedures, so it cannot separate them. The deciding detail is whether the learner earned the reward by doing something named or by going without the behavior for a set time.

Scenario 1. Mia grabs toys from peers. The plan says to praise and give the toy when she says "my turn." Reinforcement follows a named request, so this is DRA.

Scenario 2. Theo gets a sticker each time 3 minutes pass with no spitting. Spitting restarts the clock. Nothing specific is required, so this is DRO.

Scenario 3. Ava flaps her hands. She earns praise and a favorite song for holding a ball with both hands. She cannot hold the ball and flap at once, so this is DRI, a form of DRA.

Scenario 4. Leo yells for attention. Every 2 minutes, the technician chats with him whether or not he yelled. Attention arrives on a schedule with no requirement at all, so this is NCR, not DRO.

Scenario 5. Jada calls out answers. She earns a point each time she raises her hand and waits to be called on. A named behavior earns the point, so this is DRA.

How do DRI, DRL and NCR differ from DRA and DRO?

DRI reinforces a behavior that cannot happen at the same time as the problem behavior. DRL reinforces a behavior when it happens less often, not when it stops. NCR delivers the reinforcer on a time schedule regardless of behavior. DRI is a subtype of DRA, while DRL and NCR are separate procedures.

ProcedureWhat earns the reinforcerQuick clue
DRIAn incompatible behaviorThe two cannot happen at once
DRLA lower rate of the behaviorThe behavior is fine, just too frequent
NCRNothing; time aloneNo contingency on any behavior

When does a supervisor choose DRA or DRO?

A supervisor often picks DRA when the learner can be taught a better way to get the same outcome, because it builds a useful skill. DRO is often chosen when no clear replacement exists, when the behavior is dangerous and any reduction matters, or as a starting point while a replacement skill is being taught.

The choice belongs to the supervisor, based on assessment and the function of the behavior. A technician carries out the written plan, records data and reports problems, such as a learner who loses every DRO interval. You do not switch procedures on your own.

What are common mistakes with DRA vs DRO?

The most common mistake is calling any procedure with a timer DRO, even when the reward is free time-based delivery, which is NCR. Others include calling DRO the reinforcement of other behavior, forgetting that DRI is a type of DRA, and confusing DRL, which lowers a rate, with DRO, which targets zero.

  • Choosing DRO just because the problem behavior is mentioned.
  • Missing that the reward was delivered for a named action.
  • Treating a scheduled reward with no requirement as DRO.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior reduction

A technician gives a learner a token every time 5 minutes pass without hitting. Which procedure is this?

Question 2 · Behavior reduction

Problem behavior is maintained by escape from long tasks. Which change is an antecedent intervention?

Question 3 · Behavior reduction

A learner screams when a worksheet is placed on the desk, and the worksheet is then removed. The plan says to keep the worksheet in place and prompt the first problem. Which procedure is this?

Questions people ask

Is DRI a type of DRA?

Yes. DRI is DRA where the alternative behavior is physically incompatible with the problem behavior.

Does DRO use extinction?

Often, yes. The problem behavior is usually placed on extinction while intervals without it are reinforced, but follow the written plan.

Can DRA and DRO be used together?

Yes. A plan may reinforce a replacement behavior and also reward intervals without the problem behavior. The supervisor decides.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness