Differential reinforcement

Differential reinforcement means delivering reinforcement for one behavior or condition while withholding it for the problem behavior. The four common variants, DRA, DRI, DRO and DRL, differ only in what earns the reinforcer.

What is differential reinforcement?

Differential reinforcement is a behavior reduction approach that reinforces something other than the problem behavior and stops reinforcing the problem behavior itself. Because the learner still has a way to contact reinforcement, it is a positive strategy rather than a punishing one. The plan specifies what earns the reinforcer, how often, and what happens after problem behavior.

How do DRA, DRI, DRO and DRL differ?

DRA reinforces a specific alternative behavior. DRI reinforces a behavior that physically cannot happen at the same time as the problem. DRO reinforces the absence of the problem behavior across an interval. DRL reinforces the problem behavior only when it occurs at or below a set rate, because the goal is less of it, not none.

VariantWhat earns reinforcementGoalExample
DRAA named alternative behaviorReplace the problem with a useful skillHanding over a break card instead of pushing work away
DRIA behavior incompatible with the problemMake the problem physically impossible while the other occursHolding a fidget with both hands instead of scratching skin
DRONo problem behavior for a set intervalReduce the problem to zeroA sticker after each 3 minutes without spitting
DRLThe behavior at or below a set rateReduce, not eliminatePraise when the student raises a hand no more than 4 times per lesson

What does differential reinforcement look like in different settings?

The logic stays the same in every setting: decide what earns reinforcement and make sure the problem behavior no longer does. Only the behaviors and reinforcers change. In a clinic it may be tokens during table work, at home it may be screen time, and in a classroom it may be a teacher's attention.

Clinic: a learner screams to get a preferred toy. Under DRA, the technician gives the toy when the learner signs for it and does not give it after screaming.

Home: a child gets out of bed repeatedly at night. Under DRO, the plan might provide a morning reward if the child stays in bed through set intervals.

School: a student calls out answers often. Under DRL, the student earns a reward when call-outs stay under a set number, since some participation is welcome.

Why is differential reinforcement usually paired with extinction?

If the problem behavior keeps producing its reinforcer, the learner has little reason to switch to the new behavior. Pairing differential reinforcement with extinction means only the target behavior or condition pays off. That contrast is what moves responding. Without it, the procedure tends to work slowly or not at all.

What is the technician's role?

The technician delivers reinforcement exactly when the plan says, withholds it after problem behavior, times DRO and DRL intervals accurately, and records what happened. The supervisor chooses the variant, the interval and the reinforcers. If an interval seems too long or a reinforcer stops working, the technician reports it rather than adjusting it.

Common mistakes include giving the reinforcer late, so it follows a different behavior, letting a DRO timer run on after the problem occurred, and choosing an alternative behavior on the spot because it seems easier. Each one weakens the contrast the procedure depends on.

  • Restart the DRO interval after problem behavior if the plan uses a resetting interval
  • Deliver reinforcement immediately after the alternative behavior in DRA
  • Avoid accidental reinforcement, such as attention while redirecting

How can I tell the variants apart quickly?

Ask one question: what had to happen for the learner to get the reinforcer? A specific replacement behavior means DRA. A replacement that cannot coexist with the problem means DRI. Simply not doing the problem for a stretch of time means DRO. Doing the behavior, but less often, means DRL.

A common trap is calling every incompatible behavior DRA. DRI is a special case of DRA, so if the scenario stresses that both behaviors cannot happen at once, DRI is the more precise answer.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior reduction

A technician gives a learner a token every time 5 minutes pass without hitting. Which procedure is this?

Question 2 · Behavior reduction

Problem behavior is maintained by escape from long tasks. Which change is an antecedent intervention?

Question 3 · Behavior reduction

After a team stops giving attention for whining, the whining briefly becomes louder and more frequent. What is the most likely explanation?

Questions people ask

Is DRO a punishment procedure?

No. DRO delivers reinforcement. Problem behavior only resets or forfeits the interval.

Is DRI a type of DRA?

Yes. DRI is DRA with the added condition that the alternative behavior is incompatible with the problem.

When would a plan use DRL instead of DRO?

When the behavior is acceptable in smaller amounts and the goal is to reduce it rather than end it.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness