Establishing vs abolishing operation

An establishing operation (EO) increases how valuable a reinforcer is right now, and an abolishing operation (AO) decreases it. Both are motivating operations, so the quick test is direction: if the learner wants the item more than usual, think EO; if less than usual, think AO.

What is an establishing operation?

An establishing operation is a condition that makes a reinforcer temporarily more effective and makes behavior that has produced it more likely. Deprivation is the classic example: a learner who has not had a drink for two hours of outdoor play values water more and asks for it sooner and more often than usual.

EOs are not only about food and drink. Being alone for a while can raise the value of attention, and a hard task can raise the value of a break.

What is an abolishing operation?

An abolishing operation is a condition that makes a reinforcer temporarily less effective and makes behavior that has produced it less likely. Satiation is the classic example: after twenty minutes of free tablet time, a learner may show little interest in working for more tablet time, even though it usually motivates them well.

EO and AO side by side

Establishing operationAbolishing operation
Effect on reinforcer valueIncreases itDecreases it
Effect on related behaviorMore likely, right nowLess likely, right now
Typical causeDeprivation, discomfort, a hard taskSatiation, recent free access
ExampleNo attention for a long phone callJust finished a long chat with a favorite adult
What you might noticeFaster, more frequent requestsSlow responding, refusing the usual reward

How do you tell an EO from an AO on the exam?

Look for the direction of change in the reinforcer's value. Phrases such as "has not had," "went without" or "was alone for" signal an EO. Phrases such as "just ate," "had unlimited access" or "played with it all morning" signal an AO. Then check that behavior moved the same way the value did.

  • Value up, behavior up: EO.
  • Value down, behavior down: AO.
  • No change in value, only in availability: think SD, not an MO.

Worked scenarios, answered: EO or AO

Scenario 1. A learner's yelling is maintained by attention. On days when the caregiver is busy cooking for an hour, yelling starts sooner. The hour without attention is an EO for attention.

Scenario 2. Before a session, the learner eats a full bag of the chips used as reinforcers. During the session, chip-earning responses slow down. That is an AO.

Scenario 3. A technician gives a learner free access to bubbles for ten minutes before a session where bubbles are the reward. Responding drops. The free access acted as an AO, so the plan may limit access before sessions.

Scenario 4. A learner who finds a math worksheet hard begins asking for breaks more often as the worksheet gets longer. The growing task difficulty is an EO for escape.

What are the common traps with EO vs AO?

A common trap is thinking an AO removes the reinforcer. It does not; the item is still there, it just matters less for now. Another is calling an EO a reinforcer. The EO comes before behavior and changes value; the reinforcer comes after behavior. A third is forgetting that MO effects are temporary.

  • Treating satiation as a permanent loss of preference.
  • Calling a noisy classroom an SD when the item describes it making breaks more valuable.
  • Overlooking that an EO for escape can explain behavior during hard tasks.

When would you see an EO or AO in a session?

You see EOs when contrived motivation is part of mand training and when hard tasks make breaks valuable. You see AOs late in sessions, after snacks, or when a learner had free access to the reward item at home. Noticing them helps explain changes in responding that are not about skill.

Record what happened before the session, such as a big breakfast or a long video at home, and tell your supervisor when a reinforcer suddenly stops working. Your supervisor may rerun a preference assessment or rotate reinforcers; you do not withhold food, drink or comfort to create motivation.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior assessment

This morning's assessment ranked crackers as Elena's top item. After a large lunch, Elena, age 7, pushes the crackers away each time they are offered for correct responses. Her plan allows quick preference checks during sessions. What should the technician do?

Question 2 · Behavior acquisition

Praise was paired with edibles when Zoe, 7, started services. For several months since, the team has given praise alone and never paired it with anything else, and praise no longer seems to affect her behavior. What is the most likely reason?

Question 3 · Behavior acquisition

Halfway through a session, Sam, 4, has earned the same fruit snacks on 30 trials. He is now pushing them away and responding slowly. What is the best next step for the technician?

Question 4 · Behavior acquisition

A technician wants to teach Ruby, 5, to ask for water. When is Ruby most likely to be motivated to request it?

Questions people ask

Is deprivation always an EO?

Deprivation of a reinforcer generally raises its value, so it acts as an EO for that reinforcer. Basic needs are never withheld to create motivation.

Do EOs and AOs only affect food?

No. They affect any reinforcer, including attention, breaks, toys and activities.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness