Shaping vs chaining

Shaping builds one new behavior by reinforcing successive approximations that come closer to the goal, while chaining teaches a sequence of separate steps that link together into a complex skill. The quick test: is the learner improving one response, or learning to do several distinct steps in order?

What is shaping?

Shaping is reinforcing successive approximations of a target behavior while withholding reinforcement for earlier, less accurate versions. Each time the learner meets the current step, the criterion moves a little closer to the goal. Teaching a learner to say "water" by first reinforcing "wa," then "wah-t," then "water" is shaping.

Shaping works on a dimension of a single response, such as its form, loudness, duration or accuracy. Moving too fast or too slow through the steps is the usual source of trouble.

What is chaining?

Chaining teaches a behavior chain: a series of separate responses performed in order, where each step serves as the cue for the next. A task analysis breaks the skill into steps, such as the steps of brushing teeth, and the learner is taught them using forward, backward or total task chaining as the plan says.

Shaping and chaining side by side

ShapingChaining
What is taughtOne behavior, refinedSeveral behaviors, linked
Starting toolA list of approximationsA task analysis of steps
What is reinforcedThe current approximationCompleted steps or the whole chain
ExampleRaising a whisper to a conversational voicePutting on a coat in five steps
VariantsShaping across one dimension at a timeForward, backward, total task

How do you tell shaping from chaining on the exam?

Ask whether the scenario lists different actions or different versions of one action. Separate actions in order, like turn on tap, wet hands, add soap, point to chaining. Gradual change in one action, like holding eye contact for one second, then two, then four, points to shaping. The words "task analysis" almost always mean chaining.

  • Steps with different actions: chaining.
  • Same action getting closer to a target: shaping.
  • "Successive approximations" or "criterion raised": shaping.

Worked scenarios, answered: shaping or chaining

Scenario 1. A learner sits for 10 seconds at the table. The technician reinforces 10 seconds, then 20, then 40, and stops reinforcing shorter sits. One behavior, longer duration: shaping.

Scenario 2. A learner is taught to make a sandwich in seven steps from a task analysis, starting with the last step. That is backward chaining.

Scenario 3. A learner's handwriting letters are reinforced as they get closer to the line on the page. One response, improving form: shaping.

Scenario 4. A learner is prompted through every step of handwashing each trial, with prompts faded step by step. Linked steps taught together: total task chaining.

What are the common traps with shaping vs chaining?

A frequent trap is calling prompt fading shaping. When prompts are faded, the response stays the same and help is reduced, which is not shaping. Another is labelling any gradual teaching as shaping even when distinct steps are listed. A third is forgetting that a single chain step can itself be shaped if the learner cannot yet do it.

  • Treating "a little more each time" as shaping when the steps are different actions.
  • Confusing reinforcing approximations with reinforcing prompted responses.
  • Missing that a task analysis signals chaining.

When would you see shaping or chaining in a session?

You see shaping in vocal programs, tolerance goals such as sitting or wearing shoes for longer, and fine motor work. You see chaining in daily living skills like dressing, toothbrushing and making a snack. Your supervisor writes the approximations or the task analysis; you follow the current step and record data on it.

In shaping, reinforcing an earlier approximation by habit can stall progress, so keep track of the current criterion. In chaining, take data step by step so your supervisor can see exactly where the chain breaks down.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior acquisition

Ivy, 16, can do each step of starting a load of laundry, but she does them out of order, such as adding detergent after the machine is already running. Which procedure best fits this teaching need?

Question 2 · Behavior acquisition

Which statement correctly contrasts shaping and chaining?

Question 3 · Behavior acquisition

What is shaping?

Question 4 · Behavior acquisition

What is a task analysis?

Questions people ask

Can shaping and chaining be used together?

Yes. A chain step the learner cannot perform may be shaped before it is added to the chain.

Is shaping a type of differential reinforcement?

Yes. Shaping reinforces responses that meet the current criterion and withholds reinforcement for those that do not.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness