DRA vs DRI

DRA reinforces an alternative behavior that replaces the problem behavior, while DRI reinforces a behavior that is physically impossible to do at the same time as the problem behavior. DRI is a special kind of DRA, so ask one question: could the learner do both at once? If not, it is DRI.

What is DRA?

DRA, differential reinforcement of alternative behavior, reinforces a named replacement behavior and withholds reinforcement, as far as the plan allows, for the problem behavior. The replacement often meets the same need, such as asking "look at me" for attention instead of throwing items. The two behaviors could still occur together in theory.

What is DRI?

DRI, differential reinforcement of incompatible behavior, reinforces a behavior that cannot physically occur at the same time as the problem behavior. If a learner hits peers while waiting in line, reinforcing hands in pockets or holding a line rope means hitting with that hand cannot happen during the reinforced behavior.

DRI is useful when the problem is a motor behavior that can be blocked by the body's own position. It does not always teach a functional skill, so supervisors often combine it with other procedures.

DRA and DRI side by side

DRADRI
What earns reinforcementA named alternative behaviorA behavior incompatible with the problem behavior
Can both happen together?PossiblyNo, physically impossible
RelationshipThe broader categoryA specific type of DRA
ExampleSigning "break" instead of screamingSitting on hands instead of hand-biting
Typical strengthCan teach a functional communication skillDirectly competes with a motor behavior

How do you tell DRA from DRI on the exam?

First confirm a specific behavior is being reinforced; that rules out DRO and NCR. Then picture the learner doing the reinforced behavior and the problem behavior at the same moment. If it is possible, even if unlikely, choose DRA. If the body simply cannot do both, choose DRI. When both answers appear, the more specific DRI usually wins.

  • Specific behavior reinforced? If no, it is not DRA or DRI.
  • Both at once possible: DRA.
  • Both at once impossible: DRI.

Worked scenarios, answered: DRA or DRI

Scenario 1. A learner who runs from the table earns tokens for sitting with feet on the floor. Running and sitting cannot happen together: DRI.

Scenario 2. A learner who grabs peers' snacks earns praise and a snack for saying "can I have some?" He could ask and grab at once: DRA.

Scenario 3. A learner who flicks her fingers near her eyes earns a sticker for holding a fidget with both hands. Flicking and two-handed holding are incompatible: DRI.

Scenario 4. A learner who yells in class earns points for whispering to the teacher. Yelling and whispering cannot happen at the same instant, so DRI is the precise answer, although it is also a form of DRA.

What are the common traps with DRA vs DRI?

The main trap is calling a behavior incompatible because it is merely different or more appropriate. Raising a hand and calling out can happen together, so that is DRA. Another trap is forgetting that DRI is a DRA subtype, which leads to treating them as opposites. Both still depend on withholding reinforcement for the problem behavior.

  • Choosing DRI for any "good" behavior.
  • Ignoring whether the problem behavior is still being reinforced.
  • Confusing DRI with response blocking, which is a physical intervention, not reinforcement.

When would you see DRA or DRI in a session?

DRA appears in most behavior plans, often as functional communication: requesting a break, help or attention. DRI appears when a motor behavior such as hand-mouthing, hitting or elopement can be crowded out by a body position. Your supervisor names the behavior to reinforce; you deliver reinforcement quickly and consistently.

Record both the reinforced behavior and the problem behavior. If the learner does the reinforced behavior but the problem behavior is not dropping, that pattern helps your supervisor decide whether to adjust the plan.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior reduction

During circle time, Mia, 4, calls out answers. Her teacher now calls on her and praises her when she raises her hand, and does not respond when she calls out. Which procedure is this?

Question 2 · Behavior reduction

Theo, 6, flaps his hands while walking in the hallway. His plan has him carry the class supply basket with both hands, and he earns praise and a token for carrying it. Which procedure is this?

Question 3 · Behavior reduction

Noor, 9, yells to get adults' attention. Her plan says to give attention right away when she taps an adult's shoulder and to give no attention for yelling. In session, Noor yells from across the room. What should the technician do?

Question 4 · Behavior reduction

Hiro, 7, hits the table when a task gets hard, and the behavior is maintained by escape. His team teaches him to hand over a "break" card, which earns a short break from the task. What is this intervention?

Questions people ask

Is FCT a form of DRA?

Yes. Functional communication training reinforces a communication response that serves the same function, which is a form of DRA.

Does DRI need extinction too?

Usually the plan withholds reinforcement for the problem behavior. Follow the written procedure your supervisor provides.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness