Stimulus prompts vs response prompts

A response prompt is help directed at the learner's behavior, such as a verbal hint, a gesture, a model or physical guidance, while a stimulus prompt changes the teaching materials themselves, such as their position, size, color or added cues. Ask: did the teacher do something to guide the learner, or did the materials change?

What are response prompts?

Response prompts are actions by the teacher that help the learner make the correct response. Common types include verbal prompts, gestural prompts such as pointing, model prompts that show the response, and physical prompts that guide the learner's body. They are added on top of the instruction and are faded using a prompt hierarchy or time delay.

What are stimulus prompts?

Stimulus prompts alter the stimulus materials to make the correct choice stand out. Placing the correct card closer to the learner, making it larger, highlighting it, or adding a picture under a written word are stimulus prompts. They are faded by gradually returning the materials to normal, which is called stimulus fading or, for changing shape, stimulus shaping.

Positional and visual prompts fall here. Some lists treat them separately, but on the exam they count as changes to the materials, not to the teacher's behavior.

Stimulus and response prompts side by side

Response promptStimulus prompt
What is changedThe teacher's added helpThe materials
ExamplesPointing, saying the first sound, hand-over-handMoving the card closer, enlarging or coloring it
How it is fadedPrompt hierarchy, time delayStimulus fading or stimulus shaping
Who controls itThe person teaching, trial by trialBuilt into how materials are set up
Typical riskPrompt dependence on the teacherLearner responds to the added cue, not the real one

How do you tell stimulus from response prompts on the exam?

Picture the teaching table with the teacher removed. If the help would still be there, built into the cards or objects, it is a stimulus prompt. If the help disappears with the teacher because it was a word, gesture, demonstration or touch, it is a response prompt. Pointing is a response prompt even though it directs attention to the materials.

  • Words, gestures, models, touch: response prompts.
  • Position, size, color, added pictures: stimulus prompts.
  • Pointing: gestural, so response prompt.

Worked scenarios, answered: stimulus or response prompt

Scenario 1. In a receptive ID program, the technician puts the target card a few inches closer to the learner than the distractors. Stimulus prompt (positional).

Scenario 2. The technician taps the correct card. Response prompt (gestural).

Scenario 3. To teach sight words, the word "stop" is printed in red on a stop-sign shape, and the shape is faded across sessions. Stimulus prompt with stimulus fading.

Scenario 4. The technician says "buh" to help the learner say "ball." Response prompt (partial verbal).

What are the common traps with stimulus vs response prompts?

The usual trap is classifying pointing as a stimulus prompt because it involves the materials. It is a gesture, so it is a response prompt. Another trap is forgetting to fade stimulus prompts; a learner can learn to pick the biggest card rather than the right one. A third is assuming stimulus prompts are always less intrusive.

  • Treating any visual help as a stimulus prompt, including a gesture.
  • Leaving a positional cue in place by accident during probes.
  • Fading too quickly and causing errors.

When would you use each in a session?

Response prompts appear in almost every program: you give the prompt the plan specifies and fade it on schedule. Stimulus prompts appear in matching, receptive identification, reading and visual schedules, where materials are set up with the cue and changed across sessions. Your supervisor chooses the prompt type; you deliver and fade it exactly as written.

Record the prompt level for every trial. Watch for accidental prompts, such as glancing at the correct card or always placing it in the same spot, because they act as unplanned prompts and inflate the data.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior acquisition

Which of the following is a stimulus prompt rather than a response prompt?

Question 2 · Behavior acquisition

To teach Elena, 6, to read the word 'apple,' the technician prints the word over a bright picture of an apple. Over sessions the picture gets lighter until only the printed word remains. What is this procedure called?

Question 3 · Behavior acquisition

Which of these prompts is generally considered the most intrusive?

Question 4 · Behavior acquisition

A learner reliably touches the correct card when the technician points to it. The plan says to move from the gesture prompt toward no prompt. What is this process called?

Questions people ask

Is a visual schedule a stimulus prompt?

It works as a visual support built into the environment, so it is closer to a stimulus prompt than a response prompt.

Which prompts are most intrusive?

Physical prompts are generally considered the most intrusive response prompts. Your plan's hierarchy sets the order.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness