Time-out vs response cost
Time-out removes the learner's access to reinforcement for a set period after a problem behavior, while response cost removes a specific amount of a reinforcer the learner already has, such as tokens or minutes. Both are negative punishment. Ask: was the learner cut off from reinforcement for a while, or did they lose something they had?
What is time-out?
Time-out from positive reinforcement is a procedure in which the learner loses access to reinforcement for a brief, specified time after a problem behavior. It can be nonexclusionary, where the learner stays in the room but reinforcement stops, or exclusionary, where the learner is moved away from the activity. It only works if the time-in setting is reinforcing.
What is response cost?
Response cost is the removal of a specified amount of a reinforcer contingent on a problem behavior. Losing two tokens for throwing materials, or five minutes of tablet time for swearing, are examples. The learner keeps access to the activity; what changes is the amount of reinforcement they hold. It is often built into token systems.
Time-out and response cost side by side
| Time-out | Response cost | |
|---|---|---|
| What is removed | Access to reinforcement, for a time | A set amount of a reinforcer already earned |
| Duration involved | Yes, a time-out period | No, the loss happens at once |
| Learner location | May stay or be moved, depending on type | Stays in the activity |
| Example | Toy and attention paused for 1 minute after hitting | Two tokens removed after hitting |
| Key risk | Can reinforce escape-maintained behavior | Learner may run out of tokens and disengage |
How do you tell time-out from response cost on the exam?
Look at what disappears and for how long. If reinforcement is unavailable for a period of time and then returns, it is time-out. If a countable reinforcer the learner already earned is taken away and does not come back, it is response cost. Both decrease behavior by removing something, so neither is negative reinforcement.
- Clock running, reinforcement paused: time-out.
- Tokens, points or minutes subtracted: response cost.
- Something unpleasant added: positive punishment, not either.
Worked scenarios, answered: time-out or response cost
Scenario 1. During a group game, a learner grabs a peer's piece. The plan has the learner sit out of the game, still in the room, for two minutes. Time-out, nonexclusionary.
Scenario 2. A learner earns points for work. Each time she rips a worksheet, three points are removed. Response cost.
Scenario 3. A learner who screams to avoid tasks is sent to a quiet corner, and screaming increases. The time-out let him escape the task, so it worked as negative reinforcement. The supervisor needs to know.
Scenario 4. A teen loses ten minutes of evening video time for each curse word, per a written plan. Response cost.
What are the common traps with time-out vs response cost?
The most dangerous trap is using time-out for escape-maintained behavior, because removing the learner from demands can reinforce the behavior. Another is confusing response cost with extinction; extinction withholds the reinforcer that maintains the behavior, while response cost takes away a different, earned reinforcer. A third is thinking either procedure is the technician's choice.
- Calling time-out negative reinforcement because something is removed.
- Extending a time-out beyond the written duration.
- Using response cost without the plan specifying amounts.
When would you see either in a session?
You would only use time-out or response cost if your supervisor wrote it into the behavior plan and trained you on it. RBTs do not select punishment procedures. When they are in a plan, they usually sit alongside reinforcement for appropriate behavior, and data on their effects and side effects must be recorded carefully.
Follow the exact duration, location and amounts in the plan. Record each use, and report emotional responses, aggression or avoidance of you or the setting, since these side effects tell your supervisor whether the procedure should continue.
Practice questions
Andre, 10, uses a token board. His plan says that one earned token is removed each time he throws materials. What is this procedure called?
When Dmitri, 5, throws toys during play group, his plan says to have him sit in a chair at the side of the room for 1 minute without toys or interaction, then return to the group. What is this procedure?
Jasmine, 8, kicks her desk during math, and the team believes the kicking is maintained by escape. A new staff member starts sending her to a time-out corner each time she kicks, and kicking increases. What is the most likely explanation?
A technician thinks response cost would reduce a learner's spitting, but the behavior plan contains no punishment procedures. What should the technician do?
Questions people ask
Are time-out and response cost negative punishment?
Yes. Both remove something to decrease behavior, which makes them negative punishment.
Can a learner go into debt with response cost?
Plans usually avoid it, because a learner with no tokens left has little reason to keep working. Follow the written rules.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness