Response cost

Response cost is a behavior-reduction procedure in which a specific amount of a reinforcer the learner already has is taken away right after a problem behavior. It is a form of negative punishment: something is removed, and the behavior becomes less likely.

What is response cost in ABA?

Response cost means losing part of an earned reinforcer, such as a token, a point or a few minutes of a preferred activity, immediately after a target behavior. Because a stimulus is removed and the behavior then decreases, it is negative punishment. The loss is defined in advance, so the learner knows exactly what will happen.

What does response cost look like in a session?

A typical example is a token board. The learner has earned several tokens, throws materials, and one token is taken off the board without discussion. The plan states the size of the loss, which behavior triggers it, and when tokens can be earned back or spent. The technician follows those steps exactly.

Home example: a teenager earns 30 minutes of game time for finishing homework. Under a written plan, each instance of shouting at a sibling costs five of those minutes. The cost is small, predictable and applied calmly, and appropriate behavior keeps earning time.

Because the learner can only lose what they have, response cost needs a rich supply of earned reinforcers. If the balance is empty, there is nothing to take away and the procedure stops working.

How is response cost different from time-out?

Both are negative punishment, but they remove different things. Response cost takes away a reinforcer the learner already holds and the learner stays in the activity. Time-out removes access to reinforcement for a period, often by moving the learner away from the activity. One takes a token; the other takes the opportunity.

Response costTime-out
What is removedA specific amount of an earned itemAccess to reinforcement for a set time
Learner's locationUsually stays in the activityOften moved or excluded from the activity
ExampleLosing one token for throwing a pencilSitting out of the game for two minutes

What exam traps involve response cost?

The common traps are calling it negative reinforcement, mixing it up with time-out, and forgetting the learner must have something to lose. Negative reinforcement strengthens behavior; response cost weakens it. Watch the verb in the question: if the behavior decreased after something was taken away, the answer points to negative punishment.

  • Taking away a privilege after behavior and seeing it drop is punishment, not reinforcement
  • A fine for an earned token is response cost; sitting out is time-out
  • A procedure is only punishment if the behavior actually decreases
  • Losing something the learner never had is not response cost

What is the RBT's role with response cost?

Technicians do not choose punishment procedures. A supervisor designs response cost, writes the details into the behavior plan and trains you to run it. You apply it as written, keep it free of anger or lectures, record the behavior and the tokens lost, and report side effects such as escalation or avoidance of sessions.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior reduction

Andre, 10, uses a token board. His plan says that one earned token is removed each time he throws materials. What is this procedure called?

Question 2 · Behavior reduction

Each time Callie, 11, talks back, her parent takes 10 minutes off her video game time for that evening. Over the next month, talking back decreases. Which principle is at work?

Question 3 · Behavior reduction

When Dmitri, 5, throws toys during play group, his plan says to have him sit in a chair at the side of the room for 1 minute without toys or interaction, then return to the group. What is this procedure?

Question 4 · Behavior reduction

A technician thinks response cost would reduce a learner's spitting, but the behavior plan contains no punishment procedures. What should the technician do?

Question 5 · Behavior reduction

After response cost is added to Lina's sessions in the speech room, she starts hiding under the coat rack when it is time to go to that room. What does this most likely show?

Questions people ask

Can an RBT decide to start using response cost?

No. Punishment procedures are chosen and written by the supervisor. If you think one is needed, raise it in supervision.

Is response cost the same as a fine?

In everyday language, yes, but in ABA the loss must be planned, small, consistent and tied to a specific behavior.

Does response cost work without reinforcement for good behavior?

It is generally paired with a way to earn reinforcers, because the learner needs something to lose and something to work toward.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness