Discrimination training
Discrimination training teaches a learner to respond one way in the presence of one stimulus and not in the presence of others. Responses are reinforced when the discriminative stimulus (SD) is present and not reinforced when an S-delta is present, until the stimulus reliably controls the response.
What is discrimination training?
Discrimination training is a teaching procedure that brings a response under stimulus control. The technician reinforces a response when the correct stimulus is present and withholds reinforcement when it is absent or when a different stimulus is present. Over many trials the learner responds to the relevant feature of the situation rather than to chance, habit or an accidental cue.
It is task C.6 on the RBT Test Content Outline (3rd ed.), and it sits underneath a large share of everyday programs: receptive identification, labeling, sorting, following classroom signals and knowing when a behavior is appropriate.
How do the SD and the S-delta differ?
The SD signals that a particular response will be reinforced. The S-delta signals that the same response will not be reinforced. The difference is not about the stimulus itself but about its history with reinforcement. A blue card is an SD when the instruction is touch blue, and an S-delta when the instruction is touch yellow.
| SD | S-delta | |
|---|---|---|
| What it signals | Reinforcement is available for the response | Reinforcement is not available for the response |
| What the technician does after the response | Delivers the planned reinforcer | Withholds reinforcement or follows the plan's correction |
| Classroom example | Teacher says questions, anyone, and hand-raising earns a turn | Teacher is mid-explanation, and hand-raising earns no turn |
How do you set up a discrimination trial correctly?
Present the target among other choices, called a field or array, so the learner has to discriminate. Rotate the target's position randomly, vary the order of targets across trials, give the instruction once, and keep your face and hands neutral. A target presented alone teaches no discrimination, because any response to it looks correct.
- Use the array size the plan specifies, often three cards for receptive tasks
- Shuffle positions so the correct item is not usually on the same side
- Avoid patterns such as always alternating two targets
- Look at the learner, not at the correct item, while waiting for the response
- Reinforce correct responses immediately and follow the plan's error correction for incorrect ones
What is faulty stimulus control and how do you avoid it?
Faulty stimulus control means the learner responds to an irrelevant cue instead of the intended one. Common culprits are the item's position, the order of trials, the technician's glance, or the way materials are handed over. Data can look excellent while the learner has learned the wrong thing, which becomes obvious when the accidental cue disappears.
Clinic example: a learner scores 100 percent on touch the cup for a week, but the cup was always placed nearest to the learner's dominant hand. When another technician shuffles the array, accuracy drops to chance. The skill was position, not cup.
Home example: a parent always asks show me the dog right after show me the cat, so the learner simply touches whichever card was not touched last.
What exam traps involve discrimination training?
Expect scenarios that describe overgeneralization, such as a toddler calling every four-legged animal a dog, and ask what the learner needs. The answer is discrimination training, not more generalization. Other traps include a single-card array, a target always in the same spot, and confusing the S-delta with a punisher. An S-delta only signals that reinforcement is unavailable.
Worked scenario: a learner touches the red card on every trial, but red is the only card on the table. Asked what is wrong, pick the answer that adds other cards to the array. Touching the only option shows the learner can touch a card, not that the learner can tell red from other colors.
What is the technician's role compared with the supervisor's?
The BCBA selects targets, the size and composition of arrays, the mastery criterion and the error correction procedure. The technician presents trials cleanly, rotates materials as the plan directs, delivers reinforcement only after correct responses and records accurately. If performance collapses when someone else runs the program, report it, because that often points to a hidden cue.
Practice questions
In discrimination training, what is the stimulus that signals a response will be reinforced?
Tomas, 9, is learning to raise his hand after his teacher says 'Any questions?' Hand-raising while she is reading a story aloud is not reinforced. In this program, the teacher reading aloud is best described as what?
Ezra, 3, says 'dog' when he sees dogs, cats, horses and cows. Which procedure does he most need?
A technician is teaching Aria, 4, to touch the color red. On every trial, a red card is the only card on the table. Why might this be a problem?
During teaching, a technician placed the correct picture on the right side of a three-card array on nearly every trial, and Ben, 6, scored 100%. When another technician mixed up the positions, Ben kept touching the right-hand card and scored about 33%. What best explains this?
Questions people ask
Is discrimination training the opposite of generalization?
They work together. Discrimination narrows responding to the right stimuli, and generalization extends it to all relevant examples of those stimuli.
Can an S-delta become an SD later?
Yes. The same stimulus can serve as an SD in one program and an S-delta in another, depending on what is being reinforced.
Is a conditional discrimination different?
In a conditional discrimination the correct choice depends on another stimulus, such as the spoken instruction deciding which card is correct.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness