SD vs S-delta
An SD (discriminative stimulus) is a cue in whose presence a response has been reinforced, and an S-delta is a cue in whose presence the same response has not been reinforced. Both are defined by their history with one particular response, so ask: when this cue is present, does responding pay off?
What is an SD?
An SD is a stimulus that signals reinforcement is available for a specific response. Because responding in its presence has paid off before, the learner becomes more likely to respond when it appears. A technician saying "touch red" with three cards on the table is an SD for touching the red card.
The SD does not force the response. It sets the occasion for it. Over many trials the learner's behavior comes under the control of that cue, which is what stimulus control means.
What is an S-delta?
An S-delta is a stimulus in whose presence a given response has not been reinforced, so the response becomes less likely when it is present. In the same red-card drill, the blue and green cards are S-deltas for touching: touching them earns nothing, and over trials the learner stops choosing them.
An S-delta is not a punisher and not a "no" signal. Nothing unpleasant has to follow. It simply marks a condition where the response has gone unreinforced.
SD and S-delta side by side
| SD | S-delta | |
|---|---|---|
| History with the response | Response reinforced in its presence | Response not reinforced in its presence |
| Effect on responding | Response more likely | Response less likely |
| Red-card drill example | The red card when asked to touch red | The blue and green cards |
| Everyday example | Ice cream truck music for asking a parent for money | A closed shop sign for trying the door |
| Role in discrimination training | The cue you reinforce responding to | The cue you do not reinforce responding to |
How do you tell an SD from an S-delta on the exam?
Name the response first, then ask what happens when the learner makes that response with this cue present. If reinforcement follows, the cue is an SD. If reinforcement does not follow, it is an S-delta. The same object can be an SD for one response and an S-delta for another, so never classify a cue without its response.
- Identify the target response in the item.
- Find the cue that is present when the learner responds.
- Reinforced in that cue's presence: SD.
- Not reinforced in that cue's presence: S-delta.
Worked scenarios, answered: SD or S-delta
Scenario 1. A learner is taught to say "bus" when shown a picture of a bus, and earns praise each time. The bus picture is the SD for saying "bus."
Scenario 2. In the same program a truck picture is shown, and saying "bus" to it earns no praise. The truck picture is an S-delta for saying "bus." It may later become an SD for saying "truck."
Scenario 3. A child asks his grandmother for candy and usually gets it, but asking his father never works. Grandma is an SD for asking; Dad is an S-delta for asking.
Scenario 4. A green light on a toy dispenser means pressing the button drops a toy; when the light is off, pressing does nothing. Green light: SD. Light off: S-delta.
What are the common traps with SD vs S-delta?
The biggest trap is treating an S-delta as a punisher or a warning. It is only a cue linked to no reinforcement. Other traps are classifying a cue without naming the response, confusing an SD with a motivating operation, and assuming an instruction is an SD before the learner has any history with it.
- Calling a reprimand an S-delta. A reprimand that follows behavior is a consequence, not an antecedent cue.
- Forgetting that each card in an array can be an SD or S-delta depending on the instruction.
- Mixing up "wants it" (motivation) with "can get it here" (SD).
When would you see an SD or S-delta in a session?
Every discrete trial starts with an SD, and every field of choices contains S-deltas. You present the SD exactly as written, reinforce correct responses to it, and withhold reinforcement for responses to the distractors. Inconsistent delivery, such as rewording the instruction each trial, makes it harder for stimulus control to develop.
Your supervisor decides which cues to teach and how to arrange the array. Your part is consistent presentation, rotating card positions as the plan says, and accurate data, so the supervisor can see whether the learner is responding to the right cue rather than to position or your glances.
Practice questions
In discrimination training, what is the stimulus that signals a response will be reinforced?
Tomas, 9, is learning to raise his hand after his teacher says 'Any questions?' Hand-raising while she is reading a story aloud is not reinforced. In this program, the teacher reading aloud is best described as what?
How is a discrimination usually established in discrimination training?
During teaching, a technician placed the correct picture on the right side of a three-card array on nearly every trial, and Ben, 6, scored 100%. When another technician mixed up the positions, Ben kept touching the right-hand card and scored about 33%. What best explains this?
Questions people ask
Is SD the same as an instruction?
Often, but not always. An instruction becomes an SD only after responding to it has been reinforced. Pictures, objects, people and settings can be SDs too.
Can an S-delta become an SD?
Yes. If the reinforcement history changes, the cue's role changes. A distractor card in one program can be the target card in the next.
Is S-delta the same as extinction?
No. Extinction is a procedure that stops reinforcing a previously reinforced response. An S-delta is a cue linked to no reinforcement for a response.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness