Replacement behavior
A replacement behavior is an appropriate behavior that serves the same function as a problem behavior and is taught to take its place. A learner who screams for a break can be taught to hand over a break card, which earns the same break more efficiently.
What is a replacement behavior?
A replacement behavior is a socially acceptable response that gets the learner the same outcome as the problem behavior. It is chosen by the supervisor from assessment information, taught explicitly, and reinforced. It should be at least as easy and quick as the problem behavior so the learner has a real reason to use it.
What does a replacement behavior look like in a session?
For attention-maintained calling out, the replacement might be raising a hand. For tangible-maintained grabbing, it might be asking for the item. For escape-maintained tearing of paper, it might be requesting a break. The technician teaches the response, prompts it early, reinforces it immediately, and does not reinforce the problem behavior.
A useful test is whether the replacement earns the same payoff. Teaching a learner to point to an item won't help if the problem behavior was about avoiding a task; the replacement has to produce a break.
A replacement behavior is also not the same as simply any good behavior. Sitting quietly is lovely but may not give the learner what the problem behavior gave them.
How is it different from an alternative behavior or a skill target?
An alternative behavior in DRA may be any appropriate behavior chosen to reinforce. A replacement behavior specifically serves the same function as the problem behavior. A skill target is any skill being taught, whether or not it relates to problem behavior. FCT teaches a communication replacement; other replacements might be coping or self-management skills.
| Term | Tied to function? | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement behavior | Yes | Break card for escape-maintained screaming |
| Alternative behavior (DRA) | Not necessarily | Using a fidget toy |
| Skill target | No | Naming colors |
What exam traps involve replacement behaviors?
The trap is picking a behavior that does not match the function. If a learner screams to get a toy, teaching them to ask for a break is the wrong replacement. Another is assuming that teaching a replacement is enough without stopping reinforcement of the problem behavior. A third is thinking a replacement must be vocal.
- Must serve the same function
- Should be easy for the learner to do
- Must be reinforced reliably
- Problem behavior should not keep paying off
What is the RBT's role with replacement behaviors?
You teach and reinforce the replacement exactly as the plan describes, use the prompts and fading steps specified, record how often it occurs, and report when it is not being used or when problem behavior continues to work. Choosing a different replacement belongs to the supervisor.
Practice questions
Hiro, 7, hits the table when a task gets hard, and the behavior is maintained by escape. His team teaches him to hand over a "break" card, which earns a short break from the task. What is this intervention?
Ivy, 6, screams when other children are on the playground swing, and screaming is maintained by getting a turn on the swing. Which replacement response best fits functional communication training for her?
Two learners at the same clinic hit their heads with their hands. For one, adults rush over to comfort him afterward. For the other, the behavior usually ends a grooming routine. What does this show?
Noor, 9, yells to get adults' attention. Her plan says to give attention right away when she taps an adult's shoulder and to give no attention for yelling. In session, Noor yells from across the room. What should the technician do?
Questions people ask
Does a replacement behavior need to be vocal?
No. Gestures, cards, signs and devices can all serve.
How is a replacement behavior chosen?
By the supervisor, using what assessment shows about the function of the problem behavior.
What if the learner doesn't use the replacement?
Report it. It may need more teaching, easier effort, or faster reinforcement.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness