DRA (differential reinforcement of alternative behavior)

DRA stands for differential reinforcement of alternative behavior. It is a procedure in which an appropriate alternative behavior is reinforced while the problem behavior is no longer reinforced. The alternative does not have to be physically incompatible with the problem behavior.

What is DRA in ABA?

DRA is a differential reinforcement procedure with two parts: reinforce a chosen alternative behavior, and withhold reinforcement for the problem behavior. The alternative should serve the same purpose for the learner. Over time the alternative is used more because it works, and the problem behavior fades because it no longer pays off.

What does DRA look like in a session?

A learner who calls out answers is taught to raise a hand. When the hand goes up, the teacher calls on the learner and praises it; when the learner calls out, there is no attention or answer credit. The technician delivers reinforcement immediately and consistently for the alternative and follows the plan for the problem behavior.

Home example: a child grabs a parent's phone to get a turn. Under the plan, asking by tapping a card earns the phone for two minutes, and grabbing does not. Notice that the alternative here gets the same reinforcer, which is what makes DRA work.

DRA needs the alternative to be easier or at least as effective as the problem behavior. If grabbing is quicker than tapping, grabbing wins.

How is DRA different from DRI, DRO and FCT?

DRA reinforces any appropriate alternative behavior. DRI requires an alternative that cannot happen at the same time as the problem behavior. DRO reinforces the absence of the problem behavior for a set time, whatever else the learner does. Functional communication training is a DRA in which the alternative is a communication response matched to the function.

ProcedureWhat is reinforcedExample for hand-flapping
DRAAn appropriate alternativeUsing a fidget toy
DRIA behavior that cannot occur with the problemHolding the supply basket with both hands
DRONo problem behavior for an intervalA token after two minutes without flapping

What exam traps involve DRA?

The usual traps are choosing DRA when the question describes a behavior that cannot occur alongside the problem behavior (that is DRI), or when the reinforcer is for the absence of behavior (DRO). Another is forgetting that DRA without extinction for the problem behavior often fails.

  • Alternative behavior chosen and reinforced: DRA
  • Alternative physically incompatible: DRI
  • Time without the problem behavior: DRO
  • Fewer, not zero, instances: DRL

What is the RBT's role with DRA?

The supervisor selects the alternative behavior and writes the reinforcement and extinction steps. You teach and prompt the alternative as directed, deliver the reinforcer promptly, collect data on both behaviors, and report when the alternative is not being used or when the problem behavior is increasing.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior reduction

During circle time, Mia, 4, calls out answers. Her teacher now calls on her and praises her when she raises her hand, and does not respond when she calls out. Which procedure is this?

Question 2 · Behavior reduction

Noor, 9, yells to get adults' attention. Her plan says to give attention right away when she taps an adult's shoulder and to give no attention for yelling. In session, Noor yells from across the room. What should the technician do?

Question 3 · Behavior reduction

A technician gives a learner a token every time 5 minutes pass without hitting. Which procedure is this?

Question 4 · Behavior reduction

Hiro, 7, hits the table when a task gets hard, and the behavior is maintained by escape. His team teaches him to hand over a "break" card, which earns a short break from the task. What is this intervention?

Questions people ask

Does the alternative behavior have to match the function?

Plans usually choose one that does, because it can earn the same reinforcer and so competes with the problem behavior.

Is DRA a punishment procedure?

No. It uses reinforcement for a different behavior; the problem behavior simply stops being reinforced.

Why does a DRA sometimes fail?

Common reasons are slow or inconsistent reinforcement of the alternative, or the problem behavior still being reinforced.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness