S-delta

S-delta (SΔ) is a stimulus in whose presence a particular response has not been reinforced. It signals that responding right now will not pay off, which is what lets a learner tell when to respond and when not to.

What is S-delta?

S-delta is a stimulus that signals a response will not be reinforced. If a learner has been reinforced for saying 'red' when shown a red card but not when shown a blue card, the blue card is an S-delta for that response. Over time the learner stops saying 'red' for blue.

S-delta (sometimes written SΔ) works alongside the discriminative stimulus. Together they let the learner discriminate between situations.

How does S-delta show up in a session?

In discrimination training, the correct item is the SD and the incorrect items are S-deltas. Responding to an S-delta earns no reinforcer, so over trials errors drop. Outside therapy, a closed sign on a shop door is an S-delta for walking in and shopping.

Worked example: the technician lays out a cup and a shoe and asks 'Touch cup'. A touch on the cup earns praise. A touch on the shoe earns nothing and the trial is run again with a planned correction. The shoe is the S-delta for that instruction.

S-deltas can also be settings: a learner who asks for snacks at the kitchen table but not in the bathroom is responding to the different stimuli present.

How is S-delta different from the SD?

The SD signals that a response will be reinforced; the S-delta signals that it will not. Both are antecedent stimuli that come before the response. They are defined by the learner's reinforcement history in their presence, not by what they look like. The same object can be an SD in one situation and an S-delta in another.

SDS-delta
SignalsReinforcement is availableReinforcement is not available
Effect over timeResponding increases in its presenceResponding decreases in its presence
ExampleRed card when asked 'Touch red'Blue card when asked 'Touch red'

What are the common exam traps with S-delta?

A common error is treating S-delta as a punisher or as a prompt. It is neither; it is an antecedent that signals no reinforcement for a response. Another trap is calling the wrong answer itself the S-delta. The S-delta is the stimulus in whose presence the response goes unreinforced, such as the wrong card.

  • S-delta signals that reinforcement will not follow.
  • It is a stimulus, not a consequence.
  • Together with the SD, it builds discrimination.
  • Defined by history with the response, not by appearance.

How does an RBT use S-delta?

An RBT does not announce S-deltas; they appear in the materials as part of discrimination programs, such as incorrect items in an array. The RBT withholds reinforcement for responses to them as the plan states, applies the written correction procedure and records errors. Changing array difficulty is the supervisor's decision.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior acquisition

In discrimination training, what is the stimulus that signals a response will be reinforced?

Question 2 · Behavior acquisition

How is a discrimination usually established in discrimination training?

Question 3 · Behavior acquisition

During teaching, a technician placed the correct picture on the right side of a three-card array on nearly every trial, and Ben, 6, scored 100%. When another technician mixed up the positions, Ben kept touching the right-hand card and scored about 33%. What best explains this?

Questions people ask

Is S-delta a type of punishment?

No. Punishment is a consequence that reduces a behavior. S-delta is a stimulus present before the response that signals reinforcement is unavailable.

Why teach S-delta at all?

Knowing when not to respond is part of discrimination. Without it, a learner may say 'cup' to every object.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness