Fixed interval vs variable interval

A fixed interval (FI) schedule reinforces the first response after the same amount of time has passed, while a variable interval (VI) schedule reinforces the first response after an amount of time that changes around an average. In both, at least one response is still required once the time is up.

What is the difference between fixed interval and variable interval?

On FI 2 minutes, the first response after every two-minute period earns reinforcement. On VI 2 minutes, the wait varies, maybe one minute, then three, then two, averaging two. FI often produces a scallop: little responding early in the interval and a burst near its end. VI tends to produce a moderate, steady rate because the next opportunity is unpredictable.

A response is required on both. Time alone never delivers the reinforcer on an interval schedule; if it did, the schedule would be a time-based delivery like noncontingent reinforcement.

Responding faster on an interval schedule does not bring reinforcement sooner, which is why interval schedules usually produce lower rates than ratio schedules.

Fixed interval and variable interval side by side

Fixed interval (FI)Variable interval (VI)
RequirementFirst response after a set timeFirst response after a time that varies
PredictableYesNo
Typical patternScallop: slow early, fast near the endModerate, steady rate
Response neededYesYes
Session examplePraise for the first on-task check after each 5 minutesPraise for on-task behavior at unpredictable times averaging 5 minutes
Everyday exampleChecking the oven more as the timer nears zeroChecking for a text from someone who replies at random times

How do you tell fixed interval and variable interval apart on the exam?

First confirm the schedule is about time passing, not a response count. If the wait is the same every time, it is fixed interval. If the wait changes and is described as an average, it is variable interval. Then check that a response is required after the time passes; if nothing is required, it is not an interval schedule at all.

  • Time-based with a required response: interval schedule.
  • Same wait each time: fixed interval.
  • Changing wait, given as an average: variable interval.
  • Delivered on time with no response needed: noncontingent, not an interval schedule.

Worked scenarios

Scenario 1. Every 10 minutes, the teacher checks the learner's worksheet and gives a point if he is working. Points come at the same time each round. Answer: FI 10 minutes.

Scenario 2. A technician praises the first quiet hand-raise after an average of 3 minutes, with gaps ranging from 1 to 5 minutes. Answer: VI 3 minutes.

Scenario 3. A learner waits for the bus that arrives every 15 minutes and looks down the road more and more as the time nears. Answer: an FI-like pattern, the scallop.

Scenario 4. A learner gets a snack every 5 minutes whether or not he is working. Answer: not an interval schedule; nothing is required, so this is noncontingent delivery.

What are the common traps with fixed interval and variable interval?

The most common trap is confusing interval schedules with ratio schedules, especially VI with VR. Interval schedules measure time; ratio schedules count responses. Another trap is forgetting the response requirement and treating fixed-time delivery as a fixed interval. A third is thinking responding faster on an interval schedule gets reinforcement sooner. It does not.

  • Mixing time-based and count-based schedules.
  • Missing that a response must still occur.
  • Assuming the scallop appears on variable schedules.

When would you see each in a session?

Interval schedules are common for behaviors like staying on task or sitting appropriately, where it makes more sense to check periodically than to count every response. Variable intervals are often used so the learner cannot predict the check. Your supervisor sets the interval; you use a timer, watch for the required response and deliver reinforcement when the plan says.

Vibrating timers help with variable intervals because they let you track the next check without the learner hearing it.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Behavior acquisition

A technician praises Marcus, 10, for working on his assignment, but only the first time she sees him working after each 3-minute mark on her timer. Marcus tends to work little right after praise and more as each 3 minutes comes to an end. Which schedule is in effect?

Question 2 · Behavior acquisition

Owen, 5, correctly labels a picture of a bus. His technician writes the data, sets up the next card, and about 90 seconds later says, 'Great job saying bus!' What is the main problem with this sequence?

Question 3 · Behavior acquisition

During math practice, a technician gives Andre, 11, a high five after his 3rd correct answer, then after 7 more, then after 4 more, then after 6 more. The number changes each time but averages 5. Which schedule is she using?

Questions people ask

What is a scallop on a fixed interval schedule?

It is the pattern of slow responding early in each interval that speeds up as the end of the interval approaches.

Is an interval schedule the same as interval recording?

No. Interval schedules decide when reinforcement is delivered. Interval recording is a way of collecting data.

How ready are you?

Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.

Check my readiness