Tact vs intraverbal
A tact is a verbal response controlled by something nonverbal the learner can see, hear, smell or touch, while an intraverbal is a verbal response controlled by someone else's words, with no matching item present. If the learner could answer with their eyes closed and the item gone, it is an intraverbal.
What is the difference between a tact and an intraverbal?
A tact depends on a stimulus present now: the learner says "bus" because a bus is in view. An intraverbal depends on verbal stimuli alone: the learner says "bus" in answer to "what do you ride to school?" with no bus around. Both are usually reinforced socially; the difference is whether the controlling stimulus is a thing or words.
Intraverbals also lack point-to-point correspondence with what was said. Repeating someone's words exactly would be an echoic. In an intraverbal, the answer is different from the question, as in "ready, set..." followed by "go."
Conversation is largely intraverbal: answering questions, filling in songs, telling what happened yesterday, and naming members of a category.
Tact and intraverbal side by side
| Tact | Intraverbal | |
|---|---|---|
| Controlled by | A nonverbal stimulus present now | Someone else's verbal behavior |
| Item needs to be present | Yes | No |
| Example | "Apple" while looking at an apple | "Apple" after "name a fruit" |
| Matches the words heard | Not relevant; it names a thing | No point-to-point match |
| Typical teaching | Pictures, objects, events | Fill-ins, questions, categories, conversation |
| Builds toward | Describing the world | Conversation and answering questions |
How do you tell a tact from an intraverbal on the exam?
Ask what the learner is responding to. If an object, picture, sound or action in the environment is driving the answer, it is a tact, even if an adult also asked "what is it?" If only words drive the answer, with no relevant item present, it is an intraverbal. Removing the item is the quickest mental test.
- Item present and named: tact.
- Only words present, answer differs from them: intraverbal.
- Answer repeats the words exactly: echoic, not either one.
Worked scenarios
Scenario 1. Looking at a farm puzzle, a learner says "cow" as she picks up the cow piece. Answer: tact.
Scenario 2. The technician sings "Twinkle, twinkle, little..." and the learner says "star." There is no star picture. Answer: intraverbal.
Scenario 3. Asked "what do you drink from?" with no cups in sight, a learner says "cup." Answer: intraverbal.
Scenario 4. The technician holds up a spoon and asks "what's this?" and the learner says "spoon." Answer: tact, because the spoon controls the answer; the question is a prompt that does not change the classification.
What are the common traps with tact vs intraverbal?
The usual trap is calling any answer to a question an intraverbal. If the question is "what is this?" and the item is in view, the item controls the response, so it is a tact. Another trap is calling a fill-in an echoic. Echoics copy the words heard; intraverbals produce different words in response to them.
- Classifying by the presence of a question.
- Confusing intraverbal with echoic.
- Forgetting that pictures count as nonverbal stimuli.
When would you see each in a session?
Tacts are taught with objects, picture cards, books and real events, like naming animals at a farm. Intraverbals are taught through fill-in-the-blank songs, personal questions, category naming and conversation practice. Many programs teach a word first as a tact, then as an intraverbal. Your supervisor sets the targets; you present them and record responses accurately.
When probing intraverbals, keep the item out of sight. Otherwise you may be recording a tact by accident, and the data will overstate progress.
Practice questions
Wyatt, 8, has mastered many skills at the teaching table but rarely uses them anywhere else. His supervisor adds natural environment teaching to his program. What is the most likely reason?
While teaching Mason, 3, to label 'cup,' his technician uses a plastic cup, a paper cup, a mug, a sippy cup and a teacup. What is the main purpose of using so many different cups?
A technician wants to teach Ruby, 5, to ask for water. When is Ruby most likely to be motivated to request it?
Questions people ask
Is answering "what's your name?" an intraverbal?
Yes. The answer is controlled by the spoken question and does not match its words.
Can the same word be a tact and an intraverbal?
Yes. "Dog" is a tact when a dog is in view and an intraverbal when given in answer to "what says woof?" with no dog present.
How ready are you?
Ten questions, about 3 minutes, no account. Get your readiness score and your weakest domains.
Check my readiness